We should amend the FAQ to strongly recommend or gently demand that people asking about routines or picking exercises explicitly state their goals. In fact, it's probably a good requirement for nearly all questions.
It's getting old to go through the same dance in the comments with every user. A gentle stated reminder to remember a nicely worded section of the FAQ would at least slightly reduce the number of questions where the community is asked to make a judgment in the absence of the relevant context.
("Questions" in meta don't have to be titled as a question, do they?) (Please re-tag as necessary--I'm not sure this is really a feature request...)